Hopefully it's a good read, hopefully they get a variety of contributers. I know that writing today for anything published will have way more then its fair share of critics. Social media has such an impact on everything , and with the armchair quarterbacks weighing in on everything it would be hard to please everybody.
Every now and then I'll sift thru dads 60-70's era outdoor life mags and let some excellent articles and writers take me off to another place and time. Zane Grey, Hemmingway, Jack, Charles Elliot , Townsend Whelen. Man they could spin some yarns , excellent writing . The only approval they needed was the editor and their conscience . And they told it like it was , misses , rushed shots, spooked game , getting winded or plain out witted none of the fluff you get today where it's always one shot bang flops . For myself I enjoy those old stories a little more , that being said I believe it would have been generally more well recieved on an article by article bases then today.